For Call-in or Pick-up Orders (870) 698-0200IMG_4507


Hot Plate Lunch Special (changes daily) – Served with side & dinner roll

Oven Roasted Chicken & Veggies-served with dinner roll

Meatloaf Sandwich (served on a hoagie bun with our mashed potatoes and special recipe meatloaf served with choice of side)
Open-Faced Pork Pot Roast Sandwich(served on texas toast, mashed potatoes and our pork pot roast thickened in its own gravy…mouth watering! Comes with choice of one side)  


Our Local Favorite! The casserole that started it all!   $8.49

Cheesy Chicken Spaghetti – served with home-style green beans & roll


Paninis  $8.99   (served with choice of one side):

Cody’s Chicken Club Panini (chicken, bacon, spicy ranch sauce, Colby jack cheese on sourdough)
Drew’s Hot & Spicy Panini (turkey, pepper jack cheese, sweet jalapeño relish on sourdough)

Smokey Panini (chicken, turkey, bacon, jalapeno ranch sauce, pepper jack cheese on sourdough)
Turkey Panini (turkey, tomato, dried basil, creamy Italian sauce, pepper jack cheese on sourdough)
Reuben Panini (corned beef, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing & Swiss cheese on rye)
Veggie Panini (roasted squash, zucchini, peppers, mushrooms & Swiss cheese on sourdough)
Chicken Salad Panini (Natalie’s famous chicken salad, cheddar cheese on sourdough)

Muffuletta Panini-(ham, genoa salami, provolone, olive spread on sourdough with Cajun sauce on side)

 The Natalie’s Experience:    $8.49

1. Choose from Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Cajun Chicken Salad or Pimento Cheese

2. Pick your style: White, Croissant, Wheat, Sourdough Breads or have it with Ritz or Rice Crackers.  We also offer Gluten-free bread or crackers. Want it in a wrap?  We can do that too:  spinach, wheat or flour tortilla

3. Choose your favorite side item to compliment your meal

Pick 3 Plate  $8.49 – Your choice of any 3 of our side items listed below, served with crackers.

***Please note that chicken, tuna and pimento salads are NOT part of the veggie plate options.  Thank you! 🙂

BLT Sandwich & choice of side   $7.99

Avocado Egg Salad & choice of side $9.49

Whole Shrimp & Avocado Supreme $9.99(our baby shrimp mix on top of shredded lettuce & sliced avocado topped with diced tomato & cucumber, sprinkled with black pepper) comes with choice of side

1/2 size Shrimp & Avocado Supreme $7.99  comes with choice of side

Shrimp Salad Po Boy  $9.99  our shrimp & avocado supreme served sandwich style on a hoagie bun with choice of side

**Side Options**

Tomato Basil Pasta, Old-fashioned Pasta, Cheese Tortellini, Spinach-Artichoke Dip, Crack Corn Dip, Potato Salad, Broccoli Slaw, Asian Slaw, Shrimp Pasta,  Tomatoes & Cucumbers, Chips, Macaroni & Cheese, Mashed Potatoes or our famous Sweet Green Beans.  Cup of soup can be substituted for a side.


Other Favorites  $6.49

Stuffed Tomato with Chicken Salad or Tuna Salad

Frito Pie with Cheese (add sour cream, onions or jalapenos .50 ea)

Grilled Cheese on Texas Toast with choice of side

Full Entrée Salads

Natalie’s Own Salad $8.99  Oven Roasted Chicken atop spring mix greens, strawberries, mandarin oranges, pecans, feta cheese with raspberry vinaigrette

Gwynn’s Garden Salad $8.99  Choice of Chicken or Turkey, spring mix, cucumbers, diced tomatoes, shredded cheese and choice of dressing

Soup Offerings
Soups served with ritz crackers, saltines or gluten free crackers. Our keto soups served with pork rinds.





Daily Desserts by the slice – $3.49 each (call for daily selection)IMG_4447
Dozen Cupcakes – $15 for regular flavor / $18 specialty flavor
Whole Cakes & Pies made to order (Please order 48 hrs ahead and call for pricing)

Need to take some home?  We can do just that!

Main Salads (Chicken Salad, Cajun Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, & Pimento Cheese)

8 oz. – $5.50    16 oz. – $9.50   32 oz. – $17.00

Side Deli Salads (Tomato Basil Pasta, Cheese Tortellini, Spinach-Artichoke Dip, Crack Corn Dip, Potato Salad, Broccoli Slaw, Asian Slaw, Shrimp Pasta,   Tomatoes & Cucumbers)

8 oz. – $450     16 oz. – $7 .50    32 oz. – $14.00

We also have daily fresh casseroles and frozen casseroles to go.  Please call for current list and pricing.  If you need something made special, we ask for 48 hours notice.

Natalie’s offers a full catering menu for all of your entertaining needs!  Let us plan something special for your next event, large or small….we can feed you all!